I Love N.Y. Pizza in Chapel Hill

I Love N.Y. Pizza in Chapel Hill
3.5 / 5
48 reviews

106 W Franklin St, Chapel Hill, NC 27516-2516, Chapel Hill

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
I Love N.Y. Pizza
AG
Ann Gerges
google
11.21.2024
5/5

it is so good I love it

I Love N.Y. Pizza
MF
Michael Fields
google
09.19.2018
5/5

My favorite pizza in the entire world. Buffalo chicken and meat lovers is a must.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
MK
Megan Kahane
google
08.22.2018
3/5

They were good with service around midnight on a Friday, but for a New York girl the pizza itself was subpar at best.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
hj
hyun joon shin
google
08.13.2018
3/5

It looks a day old pizza to me

I Love N.Y. Pizza
RT
Regina Torres
google
07.24.2018
5/5

Reminds me of home

I Love N.Y. Pizza
DB
Dustin Burke
google
07.17.2018
5/5

This is as close as you can get to pizza from NYC! It has a perfect flavor and huge slices. As long as I am alive, I will always be back! Go Heels!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
TT
Ted T
google
07.05.2018
3/5

It's a alright place to stop for a slice of pizza and a beer. Fast service when it's late while your hitting the bars and need a quick bite.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
LW
Lisa Williams
google
05.11.2018
4/5

Tastes almost like N.Y.C PIZZA.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
MJ
Maria Julia
google
04.25.2018
3/5

Great pizza !!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
JM
Jake May
google
04.16.2018
1/5

Nope. We've got an imposter

I Love N.Y. Pizza
SA
Sherry Appenauer
google
04.07.2018
1/5

Not crazy about this place. This our second time trying their pies. Very oilly, burnt and dry.I understand the current environment businesses are having a hard time but I think he used a pie already made andaand pepperoni.He has the time, make fresh pies.I'm from NY and I know great pies. This fell way short won't be returning.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
NR
Naomi Roberts
google
02.03.2018
1/5

Dirty and old building. The bacon is turkey bacon and tastes horrible. Go during peak hours if you want something less than an hour old. Even then, inspect what you are buying because its most likely been sitting out a while.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
BY
Brian Yang
google
10.19.2017
4/5

Cramped spaces but phenomenal pizza and quick service times!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
EB
Evan Boyle
google
10.15.2017
5/5

Pizza was good I like the ranch one

I Love N.Y. Pizza
MK
Marek K
google
10.08.2017
5/5

Good pizza

I Love N.Y. Pizza
RT
Robert Thomas
google
09.12.2017
5/5

Great pizza!!! Its truly a taste of NY in the south 😁

I Love N.Y. Pizza
MB
Mr. Burns
google
09.08.2017
4/5

Good pizza no complaints at all

I Love N.Y. Pizza
BG
Benjamin G
google
09.07.2017
5/5

Great pizza by the slice.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
WC
William Countiss
google
08.16.2017
1/5

If cleanliness isn't an issue for you be sure to drop in for a slice at a NY price. Suit up in your hazmat gear before heading into the bathroom, and be sure to sidestep the excrement that was dropped a touch shy of the toilet by a previous patron. We've all seen this before, but I got the impression that a lack of attention to the bathroom carries over elsewhere, and I was right. Most of the tables were filthy. Crumbs and dried sauce at multiple tables looked to be long time residents.You never get a second chance at a first impression, and unfortunately it was so filthy here that I decided not to eat.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
BB
Brandy Bell
google
08.03.2017
5/5

Giant slices and REALLY good!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
KP
Kenneth Parker
google
07.16.2017
3/5

Friendly service. Good selection. Excessive Mozzarella cheese.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
HD
Harrison Dale
google
07.03.2017
5/5

Hell yeah

I Love N.Y. Pizza
DH
David Heider
google
06.23.2017
5/5

Best pizza on Franklin street. Great selection and all delicious. Make sure you stop by.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
SR
Spencer Rodgers
google
06.16.2017
4/5

Big, delicious slices, a little pricy though

I Love N.Y. Pizza
hB
haley Browning
google
06.02.2017
1/5

If i could put 0 stars i would!! I knew it was a bad idea walking into the joint when i didn’t see a single soul in there. And it’s not even an odd time to eat right now...my pizza was so so so thin and oily and the flavor was similar to rotten milk! It smelled and tasted horrible, i deffinanlty DONT reccoment this place, head to a papa johns or even a dominos and it will taste better.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
LR
L. R.
google
04.24.2017
4/5

Good NY styled pizza in a quaint spot. Pizza is greasy, crust is just right. I do recommend!!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
BT
Ben Thyer
google
04.09.2017
2/5

Mediocre albeit inexpensive pizza.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
SD
Sean Dillett
google
03.01.2017
5/5

Not luxury, but you won't be disappointed if you're looking for above average NY pizza in Chapel Hill.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
ZF
Zack Fulton
google
02.08.2017
5/5

My favorite place to eat on Franklin. I always get their calzones!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
RH
Robert Hare
google
01.24.2017
3/5

Pizza is pretty bad, the calzones are great and big though

I Love N.Y. Pizza
VE
Victor Elia
google
01.19.2017
4/5

There are not many places to get a good slice in this neck of the woods. This place comes very close and is a slice of home.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
EC
google
01.05.2017
5/5

Good price for portions, and the pizza is great. Highly recommend if you're in the mood to drop in and pick up some pizza made quick!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
SJ
Stuart Joines
google
11.21.2016
5/5

Best pizza in the world! Buffalo chicken pizza incredible! I live 2.5 hours away and will drive there just for a slice of pizza or to take home a whole pie.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
DG
Deen Gu
google
11.16.2016
4/5

Don't know why this place doesn't have more customers. Solid New York Style Pizza, you know the thin slice where the cheese sort of falls off. That's my favorite kind. Only four stars because each slice is a little pricey... around $3.25 for a cheese slice.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
LH
Lara Hampton
google
10.23.2016
1/5

Pizza tasted like feet and wet towels

I Love N.Y. Pizza
RP
Rodney Pike
google
10.02.2016
1/5

I Love NY Pizza but this is not good in any state! Crust is meh, sauce is watered down tomato paste and cheese lacks any real flavor. And the cost is crazy high!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
Crystal
google
09.24.2016
3/5

My husband loves this place when he gets off work onto the bus!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
RM
Robert Mizelle
google
07.15.2016
5/5

Passing through town, ordered a large cheese pizzaAnd it was delicious Just Like New York !I know I lived there in 1980'sAnd learned to make pizza, really!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
JG
Jane Grey
google
06.22.2016
5/5

Thin crust is perfect and their 🍕 slices are just right. So yummy.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
CB
Charles Bass
google
06.10.2016
1/5

Not happy at all

I Love N.Y. Pizza
AS
Andrew Strickland
google
06.04.2016
5/5

Had a slice of the white pizza with spinach. The ricotta was amazing and made the pizza. Saw the garlic knots on the way out the door but they looked good too.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
mimicat333
google
05.18.2016
4/5

I've been living in the area for more than 10 years and somehow never got a chance to eat there. Finally my daughter and I got to stop by and decided to give it a try.We tried Pepperoni, pineapple and ham, veggie, buffalo chicken, pepperoni and sausage. Love all of them! But buffalo chicken was the best and the veggie one was kinda bland to me, probably because of all the others were way too savorier compared to the veggie type.All in all, it's a nice and easy place to hang out with friends or family on a quiet afternoon.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
PK
Peter Kidd
google
04.22.2016
3/5

Pizza was fine, but at almost $4 for a slice, expensive.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
DB
Daniel Bossut
google
03.18.2016
2/5

Trying to get a pizza delivered and 5 mi is too for or them to deliver!!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
NB
Nerth Box
google
01.22.2016
4/5

Not the best attitude from the cashier, but good pizza!

I Love N.Y. Pizza
BT
Barrel Titor
google
01.13.2016
2/5

Tasteless

I Love N.Y. Pizza
NG
Nichole Goodman
google
01.11.2016
5/5

The stromboli was enough for four people and it was delicious. I also appreciated the variety of slices. Nice atmosphere and great view of Franklin Street.

I Love N.Y. Pizza
ZC
Zac Curtis
google
01.10.2016
5/5

So dang tasty!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19199684224

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!